quote:
You're not making sense. Bama lost the first LSU game on the last play despite having more yards/first downs, etc. while injuries weren't a significant factor.

No. You are not making sense. the first game determines how the second game turns out. That's your reasoning, right? Williams would have done great things in the second game because he did in the first?

Come on, dude. You need to be consistent.

Let me see.

Texas would have won if Colt McCoy had not gotten hurt.
LSU gets the 2011 title because they won the first game in 2011, and that proves who the better team was.

At least attempt to be consistent. Or do the rules change only when Alabama is involved? Kind of like Alabama injuries and missing players affect the game but Georgia injuries and missing players do not matter?

quote:
You can draw your own conclusions.

I have drawn my own conclusions and did that based on your logic. Consistency means something.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by mbogo

Member since Oct 2012

2546 posts

Posted on 7/5/23 at 1:38 am to DawgsLife

quote:
No. You are not making sense. the first game determines how the second game turns out. That's your reasoning, right? Williams would have done great things in the second game because he did in the first?

No, my reasoning is that a team that won easily when both teams were basically even with injuries would have won the second game(that came down to the last minute) had the injury situation not be so skewed in Georgia's favor.

quote:
Texas would have won if Colt McCoy had not gotten hurt.

Certainly possible. Too bad we don't have a second game to give us a better idea.

quote:
LSU gets the 2011 title because they won the first game in 2011, and that proves who the better team was.

You are struggling trying to compare something that isn't comparable. Bama outplayed LSU both times, one was a close loss and the other was a dominating win. The Bama/Georgia games - a dominating Bama win and a last minute Georgia win with Bama down many starters out injured. Bama actually out gained Georgia in both games