re: Has college football lost its soul?

NIL simply took a black market and made it more open and public. Name Image likeness has allowed the schools and coaches that weren’t good at bribing players and getting away with it to flourish.

The new transfer rules have cheapened the old process of underclassmen waiting their turn, but it has also allowed greater parity.

Pros: Greater parity due to a decentralization of talent and resources. Life changing money for players that may not have an opportunity in the NFL. Greater chance for players to be in a position to succeed. It’s possible to build a roster in a single season.

Cons: Reduced traditions and connection between players and their chosen school. Increased program cost of success. It’s possible to lose a roster in a single season.

Ultimately I think the pros outweigh the cons.