re: Best tobacco free dip?

Just quit.

I dipped 35 years and quit last May.
I was using Red Seal Long Cut also.
The cost just got to where it wasn't worth it ($3000 a year habit).
I didn't really want to quit.

I bought the nicotine losanges (like 200).
Used about 10 of them and realized how nasty they tasted but they did help with cravings.

My uses for the oral fixation (still using these).
Jack Links Beef Jerky in a can (Terayaki flavor)..Good but expensive
Gum
Sunflower seeds (regular...$14 a case on amazon...case lasts a month).
Jolly Ranchers
Peppermints
Toothpicks

I don't regret quitting.
I was over the severe cravings in about 2 weeks.
I was over the minor cravings in about 6 months.